Case Study

Overview

A recent case handled by Rosenblum Law involved an 18-year-old international student accused of shoplifting at a Sephora store in New Jersey. The initial charge, a fourth-degree crime under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-11(b), carried severe potential penalties, including up to 18 months in jail and a $10,000 fine. The client and his family were understandably distressed, given the potential impact on his immigration status and future.

Client’s Situation

The young man, an F1 visa holder studying at a university in New York, was accused of mistakenly taking merchandise worth $311. He expressed willingness to pay for the items immediately upon realizing the oversight. However, store security detained him and he was later processed by the police, making the experience highly traumatic. His parents, respected professionals from Brazil, were deeply concerned about the repercussions of a criminal record.

Legal Strategy and Resolution

Rosenblum Law’s experienced team provided compassionate and skilled legal representation. We thoroughly investigated the case, ensuring that the client understood all aspects of the legal process and the potential consequences.

The primary defense strategy focused on negotiating a settlement that would prevent a criminal conviction, thereby protecting the client’s immigration status. Our attorneys communicated with the prosecution and the store’s loss prevention team, highlighting the client’s clean record and his valuable contributions as a student and athlete.

Outcome

Through diligent negotiation, Rosenblum Law successfully reduced the charge from a fourth-degree crime to a local ordinance (non-criminal) violation. This resolution involved a conditional discharge, meaning the client avoided a criminal record, significant fines, and jail time. The result allowed the client to continue his studies and maintain his immigration status without interruption.

Conclusion

This case exemplifies Rosenblum Law’s dedication to protecting our clients’ rights and securing favorable outcomes, even in challenging situations. Our deep understanding of both criminal defense and immigration law enabled us to achieve a resolution that safeguarded the client’s future. If you or a loved one faces similar legal challenges, our experienced attorneys are here to help you navigate the complexities of the legal system with professionalism and care.