Disorderly Conduct Lawyer NJ - 2c:33-2a

Table of Contents

Those who frequent rowdy parties or bars might be familiar with a charge of disorderly conduct. It’s a fairly minor crime that accuses a person of inappropriately rough or disruptive behavior. Simple things like yelling at someone or bumping into people (perhaps by accident) can result in being arrested for disorderly conduct.

As embarrassing as this may be, such an offense can be committed by anyone. If you or a loved one has been charged with disorderly conduct in New Jersey, it is urgent that you understand the potential penalties and contact an experienced attorney who can help protect your liberty and livelihood.

What is Disorderly Conduct?

Under N.J.S.A. 2C:33-2, disorderly conduct is a petty disorderly persons offense and is charged in two ways.

Improper Behavior [2C:33-2(a)]: This can mean one engaged in fighting, or threatening violent or tumultuous behavior. Additionally, a person who creates a hazardous or physically dangerous condition by any act that serves no legitimate purpose, he/she can also be convicted of this.

Offensive Language [2C:33-2(b)]: Although this is prosecuted much less often, a person can be convicted of disorderly conduct due to uttering offensive language in public with the purpose of offending the hearer. Also, even if the person does not intend to offend the hearer but acts in reckless disregard of doing so, he/she can still be convicted.

In this context, “public” means a place where a substantial group of people has access. In other words, highways, transport facilities, schools, prisons, apartment houses, places of business or entertainment, and neighborhoods all constitute “public” places. In most cases, even a concert hall or a sports stadium can count as a “public” place.

Penalties and Fines

Being convicted of disorderly conduct is much more serious than most think. Disorderly conduct is akin to a misdemeanor in most other states. Although it is called a “petty disorderly persons offense,” it will appear on one’s criminal record and can lead to up to 30 days in jail and a fine of up to $500. If the actions in question caused any damage to property, the judge can require the person pay restitution—i.e. to pay for repairs or replacement of the property. Like many criminal offenses, a conviction for disorderly conduct can be a red flag for many employers. It can also limit options for college and housing.

How To Beat Disorderly Conduct

Remember, everyone has constitutional rights that cannot be taken away. Just like a police officer cannot search a person simply because he wants to, he/she cannot arrest someone without an extremely good reason for doing so.

Everyone has a First Amendment right to freedom of speech. As such, as long as the words uttered do not incite an immediate breach of the peace, an officer will have a very hard time justifying an arrest for disorderly conduct due to using offensive language. This means that the prosecution will bear a heavy burden of proof whenever they try to convict someone of disorderly conduct due to uttering offensive language.

Not only can an experienced defense attorney be able to help raise this defense, but he/she can also diffuse a prosecutor’s case altogether by providing concrete evidence for why those words did not bring about or incite an immediate breach of the peace. Moreover, when it comes to disorderly conduct due to improper behavior, a good criminal defense attorney will be able to show the court that the client’s actions had a legitimate purpose and do not warrant a conviction. In many cases, it is wisest to negotiate with prosecutors to reduce the charge to a lesser offense that will not result in a criminal record.

Case Law Analysis

State v. Davis, No. A-5172-09T2

In State v. Davis, No. A 5172-09T2, the New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division reversed the conviction for disorderly conduct of Colleen Davis. Ms. Davis was stopped by the police in her car. She was belligerent and loud throughout the stop. She shouted and screamed obscenities at the police officers who stopped her. She was convicted of disorderly conduct by the trial court and again on a de novo appeal to the Law Division. She appealed to the Appellate Division of the New Jersey Superior Court. They reversed the conviction on the basis that there was no evidence that she caused “public inconvenience, annoyance, or alarm.” No bystanders were interviewed, nor were there any ascertainable consequences from her obnoxious behavior. The charge was dismissed.

State v. Stampone, 775 A.2d 193

The Appellate Division of the New Jersey Superior Court reversed the defendant’s conviction for disorderly conduct State v. Stampone, 775 A.2d 193. Similar to Davis, the defendant’s conduct arose out of a traffic stop. He was rude and yelled at the police officer who pulled him over. The Appellate Division found that, while the defendant’s conduct was unfortunate, it was not illegal. He had every right not to respond to police officers’ inquiries. Something more than obnoxiousness was required for a conviction under the statute.

State v. Shtutman, No. A–0812–15T2

In State v. Shtutman, No. A-0812-15T2, the defendant appealed his conviction for disorderly conduct to the Appellate Division of the Superior Court of New Jersey. He argued that, like in Stampone, his conduct may have been obnoxious but it was not “tumultuous” as required by the statute. The Appellate Division disagreed. In this case, the defendant was intoxicated and shouting obscenities at police and a civilian for a matter of minutes. Neighbors came out to see what was going on and the scene was described by the trial judge as “complete chaos.” The Appellate Division affirmed the conviction.

State v. Cooney, 2006 WL 1028812

A municipal ordinance prohibiting “riots, breaches of peace, and disorderly conduct” was held to be invalid in State v. Cooney, 2006 WL 1028812. In that case, the Appellate Division of the Superior Court of New Jersey heard the defendant’s appeal from a conviction under the municipal ordinance. Because of the operation of the doctrine of “preemption,” under which lower levels of government may not pass laws effectively identical to existing state criminal law, the court found that municipal ordinance was invalid. They found that the offense of disorderly conduct under 2C:33-2 preempted the offense the defendant was convicted of.

Consequences for a First Offense

As a petty disorderly persons offense, the potential jail sentence is small–only 30 days. However, unless the charge is coupled with other, more serious charges (e.g. aggravated assault), a first-offense of disorderly conduct is unlikely to result in jail time. This is known as a presumption of non-incarceration.

This doesn’t mean that judges don’t take this offense seriously. Rather, they recognize that things just got a little out of control. In the scheme of things, probation and a fine are often sufficient punishment.

While avoiding jail time is a good thing, it does not mean that the defendant has gotten off easy. The simple fact of being convicted for disorderly conduct still means having a criminal record that can affect one’s livelihood. As such, it is critical to hire an attorney to defend against a disorderly conduct charge.

Consequences for Juveniles

Kids under the age of 18 often have a lot of energy to work out, which can result in impulsive actions and aggressive language. If this behavior crosses the line in a public setting, it can lead to a charge of disorderly conduct. Juveniles charged with a minor crime will have their cases heard in Family Court. While these judges are used to dealing with kids, it is the job of a skilled defense attorney to carefully explain the difference between a child innocently acting out and one who is engaging in “tumultuous” or disruptive behavior. An attorney can explain the circumstances and present the facts in such a way so as to have the best chance of avoiding a conviction.

Enrolling in NJ Diversionary Programs

A person who is charged with disorderly conduct may be able to avoid a conviction by entering a diversionary program. In cases involving this and other petty offenses, an attorney could request a “carry order.” This is a request for the judge to delay the case for 60 to 90 days while the defendant seeks counseling. This could be anger management or alcohol/drug counseling, depending on the defendant’s situation. At the end of the carry period, if the defendant submits proof of the counseling and has remained arrest-free during that time, the charges can be dropped–no conviction, no criminal record.

Expunge Disorderly Conduct

As a petty offense, disorderly conduct can be cleared from one’s criminal record if the individual in question is otherwise eligible. A person can have his/her criminal record expunged if it has 5 or fewer disorderly persons convictions, or 3 or fewer disorderly persons convictions and no more than 1 indictable (felony) offense conviction. Note that some offenses, such as violent crimes and domestic violence-related crimes can make a record ineligible for expungement. For more information on expunging a criminal record in NJ, read our information page and contact an attorney for help.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some examples of disorderly conduct?

Any kind of aggressive or wild behavior that serves no purpose other than to annoy or upset another person could result in a charge of disorderly conduct. This may include jumping on a table or bar, pushing or shoving another person, screaming aggressively in a person’s face, and similar sort of behavior.

Can you go to jail for disorderly conduct in NJ?

Yes, a disorderly conduct conviction in NJ can result in up to 30 days behind bars, in addition to any other charges that may be filed against the individual for similar or related actions.

Is disorderly conduct the same as being a disorderly person?

Disorderly conduct and being adjudicated a disorderly person are two different things, although they can overlap. A “disorderly person” is a person who has been convicted of a disorderly persons offense in NJ, which is equivalent to a misdemeanor. Disorderly conduct is a specific type of petty disorderly persons offense.

Is swearing at a cop disorderly conduct in NJ?

Depending on the language used and other circumstances, swearing at a cop could be a form of protected First Amendment speech. However, threatening or violent language that could make an officer feel unsafe can result in a charge of disorderly conduct.

Who Should I Contact?

If you or a loved one has been cited for disorderly conduct and/or any other criminal offense in New Jersey, contact an attorney for help. The lawyers at Rosenblum Law are skilled criminal defense attorneys who can help protect your right to express yourself and mitigate the consequences of the charge. Email Rosenblum Law or call 888-815-3694 today for a free consultation about your case.